The Atlanta-based 11th Circuit Court of Appeals recently held that sharing food with the homeless in a public park by a group with a political message is considered expressive conduct and, therefore, protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The decision is the first by an appellate court on this particular issue, according to a press release issued by the attorneys for the winning litigant, the local group called Fort Lauderdale Food Not Bombs.
Food Not Bombs
The organization Food Not Bombs shares free vegetarian food on a weekly basis at events in Stranahan Park in downtown Fort Lauderdale. The group uses the service of food to communicate the message that society could end poverty as well as hunger if money and resources spent on the military were redirected elsewhere. According to the group, food is a human right. The organization sets up tables and banners during its meal distribution. It also hands out literature at its events. The logo for Food Not Bombs is a clenched fist holding a carrot.
The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects Americans’ rights to freedom of speech, press, petition, and assembly. Several types of speech are protected including core political speech, expressive speech, and most types of commercial speech. The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) has held that freedom of expression by non-speech means is also protected under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. In United States v. O’Brien, however, the SCOTUS noted regulating non-speech can justify limitations on speech.
The Appellate Decision
The appellate decision reverses the lower court’s ruling, which held that the shared meal was not expressive conduct and, therefore, not protected speech. On remand, the trial court now will have to determine whether or not the City of Fort Lauderdale’s ordinance restricting food-sharing in parks is a violation of the First Amendment. According to the appellate opinion written by Judge Adalberto Jordan, the treatment of the homeless population in the City of Fort Lauderdale is an issue for the local community. Judge Adalberto noted the food-sharing events “are more than a picnic in the park.” A reasonable observer, he continued, would infer a message about community and caring for all citizens.
The case is Fort Lauderdale Food Not Bombs v. City of Fort Lauderdale.
Certified Court Reporters
That Are Part of the Team!
Here at Elizabeth Gallo, we are very happy to be represented by our Certified Court Reporters. Unlike other major Court Reporting agencies, our Court Reporters are a part of the team and are not contracted.
What makes our Court Reporters special is that they each work hard to accommodate all of our clients. This includes from covering a series of depositions for the same client, or ensuring a rushed transcript request is met promptly.
If you or a fellow associate are in need of a Court Reporter, schedule with Elizabeth Gallo Court Reporting today!
Elizabeth Gallo Court Reporting’s Legal Fact of the Week is here to help you get through the work week by sharing a random fact about American History, law, and more! Today we focus on boating laws!
EGCR’s Legal Fact of the Week: Arizona Boating Laws
In the state of Arizona, no one under the age of 12 may operate any kind of boat that features a motor of 8 horsepower or greater. However, they are specific conditions that allow children under 12 to operate a boat. The following conditions must apply in order to be legal: 1) An emergency has taken place and no adult is available to operate the boat and 2) The child’s legal guardian or parent who is license is on the boat.
Here at Elizabeth Gallo, we love to explore apps to help create balance for our clients and colleagues working in the Legal Industry. Thus, we understand while maintaining our personal agendas, work can become intense as part of the process. Thus, some responsibilities, such has maintaining your CLE credits can be overwhelming. Today, we explore an app that you can use to refer for legal terms and sources.
This week’s Legal app is Law Dictionary & Guide
Law Dictionary & Guide is a great app to use when needing to refer to legal terms, definitions, and more. The app contains over 14,00 legal terms and vocabulary. Additionally, it includes over 600 abbreviations.
This cool dictionary app makes it easy to search and browse for certain words and terms. One can explore the app offline as well! Lastly, and to further sweeten the deal, Law Dictionary & Guide also features law journals, outlines and other legal sources.
Law Dictionary & Guide is available to download on any iOS and Android device.